‘Without tenants in any of these asset classes, we are all at a loss.’ How CREDA NJ gave voice to the state’s corporate relocation crisis
Gov. Mikie Sherrill on Tuesday took another step toward improving New Jersey’s business climate, in part by pledging to focus on retention and attraction in the wake of several high-profile corporate departures. Less than a month earlier, CREDA New Jersey highlighted that very issue through the lens of the state’s commercial real estate sector, part […]
Gov. Mikie Sherrill on Tuesday took another step toward improving New Jersey’s business climate, in part by pledging to focus on retention and attraction in the wake of several high-profile corporate departures.
Less than a month earlier, CREDA New Jersey highlighted that very issue through the lens of the state’s commercial real estate sector, part of a program that served as both a rallying cry for the industry and a closer look at how it’s impacted by the loss of companies like Samsung, Mars Snacking, Burlington Stores and others that have left the state.
“We’re going to diagnose a problem we’re experiencing,” CREDA NJ CEO Dan Kennedy said at the Oct. 15 event in Kenilworth. “Then, after tonight, the work really starts.”
Below are some highlights of the discussion, which Kennedy moderated and which featured Cushman & Wakefield’s Peter Bronsnick and SJP Properties’ Andrew Natale.
Coming to a head
Hosted at Galloping Hills Country Club, the event came just over a month after Burlington Stores announced it would move its headquarters to Philadelphia, leaving its namesake township in South Jersey after 54 years. Two months earlier, Mars Snacking revealed it would leave its office in Newark and it shift operations to Chicago, while Samsung Electronics America said in late May that it was heading to Texas after more than four decades in the Garden State.
By that point, Natale said commercial real estate leaders knew it was time to speak up.
“If there are not jobs, if there are not careers in New Jersey, we all have a problem,” said Natale, SJP’s chief operating officer. “It doesn’t matter if we’re building warehouses, if we’re attorneys negotiating our leases, if we’re in residential construction development, this is an issue that’s going to affect all of us.”
Bronsnick agreed: “Without tenants in any of these asset classes, we are all at a loss.”
The longtime industry leader, Cushman’s executive regional director for New Jersey, Pennsylvania and Delaware, said the state needs to attract employers beyond the medical and education fields, acknowledging that “there’s not a lot of ways to attract labor to a state that has an 11 percent corporate tax rate.” But New Jersey still has much to offer, he said, such as an educated labor force, a highly rated public high school system and proximity to New York City.
Asked about the state’s weaknesses, Natale said, “I think the biggest factor is the cost of doing business here.” Seven years ago, New Jersey had 25 Fortune 500 countries, but that’s down to 17. “That’s a problem, and if that continues to accelerate, that’s an epidemic,” he said.
What’s more, he said, companies aren’t waiting until their leases end to leave. Samsung was at the beginning of a 15-year term in Englewood Cliffs, while Mars was halfway through its 10-year deal in Newark. The relocations are “a problem and a red flag, because the cost of the real estate is not even factoring into this equation.”
“At the end of the day, getting somebody interested in planting their flag in New Jersey, the first hurdle is just the sheer comparison,” Bronsnick said. He cited some positives, such as increased activity on the Hudson waterfront. But with the cost of occupancy in the state, it’s tough to compete with lower-cost areas like the South and the Sun Belt.
He said diversifying employers was key, pointing to the high concentration of coders and tech labor in Hudson County, the skilled labor force in Middlesex County and the science and technology expertise from Mercer to Middlesex counties.
“We’ve got to keep people from leaving,” Natale said. “I think we should be talking to companies that are here and seeing what they need, what their challenges are … because ultimately when you find out they’re leaving, they’ve been making that decision behind closed doors for years.”
He said the film industry’s growth in the state is an example to follow, with over a billion dollars in investment. The Aspire tax credit program has also brought successes, such as the Health & Life Science Exchange or HELIX project in New Brunswick, he said.
The land use hurdle
Bronsnick said vacated corporate campuses shouldn’t sit unused. “We need to think about how we’re going to promote success stories around mixed-use master planning, the concentration of retail, the right mix of affordable housing with a multifamily component and a smaller office component.”
The panelists debated whether municipal officials are part of the problem. Natale said, “When you take a town that has a large corporate partner, a large industrial site or a large corporate pharmaceutical campus, the threat of them leaving and what that tax bill would do to that town is real. So I think you’re seeing, at the local level, the towns have woken up and they will move that quickly.” That’s less the case with new development, he said, because of the process of getting land use and other approvals.
Bronsnick said, “It’s not just the town issue, it’s a competency issue. And honestly, we need to own some of that as a community.” He noted the development process could be streamlined and that some developers might be savvier than others at dealing with municipalities.
Flight to quality (and amenities), but little growth
As for Class A office space, Bronsnick said the suburbs outperformed urban centers during the pandemic, but that was an anomaly. Growth is what’s missing now, he said.
Natale agreed. A lot of the demand he sees is from relocations or consolidations into better buildings.
“Overall, it’s not growing the jobs in the state,” he said.
The SJP executive later noted that people crave experiences since COVID, and the state has many vibrant, walkable downtowns.
“We’ve done well on building buildings where people want to work,” Natale said. “So let’s focus on what we do really well organically, because I think this state has great assets.”
On Tuesday, CREDA NJ said the state’s corporate relocation crisis has been a top policy priority since it participated in Sherrill’s transition committee. That continued with the Oct. 15 event in Kenilworth and on Oct. 30, when it led a delegation of member leaders to meet with state officials at the Newark office of Choose New Jersey, the nonprofit business attraction organization that works closely with Trenton.
What came next was a policy win, as CREDA described it, after Sherrill on Tuesday signed Executive Order No. 28 to formalize the New Jersey Means Business Economic Development Strategy. That includes four key pillars: business friendliness, sector-based growth, research and innovation and inclusive growth that works broadly.
“The actions today represent the next step in addressing New Jersey’s corporate relocation crisis head on,” Kennedy said. “This issue has been at the forefront of New Jersey’s commercial real estate industry, and we view this executive order as a step in the right direction.
“CREDA NJ has made this issue a priority, hosting a panel event last month on this very topic. Our members stand ready to support the Governor and her team — in partnership with legislative leaders — to effectively and swiftly execute the strategies contained in EO No. 28.”